You remember that one cookie—the chocolate one with the cream in the middle? This is her older, wiser, better-dressed cousin.

Walker & William’s Cookies-n-Cream Sandwich Cookie is a sophisticated take on a classic. Two scalloped chocolate shortbread rounds, dusted ever-so-lightly with powdered sugar, sandwich a rich, dreamy vanilla cream filling, double-stuffed with chocolate chips, that melts just so. It’s a cookie that knows how to behave at tea, but still knows how to have fun.

Handmade in Denver from scratch—just like Jo’s grandmother taught her—this treat delivers all the charm of the soda fountain era with the elegance of modern craftsmanship. Whether you’re sneaking one before supper or plating them for company, they’re sure to make mouths smile and hearts swoon.

Because some things never go out of style.